Member-only story

The Teacher Quality Index: An In-Depth Analysis of a Controversial Metric

Aubrey Blair

·10.7k Followers· Follow

Published in The Teacher Quality Index: A Protocol For Teacher Selection

4 min read

1.4k View Claps

94 Respond

Save

Listen

The Teacher Quality Index Graphic The Teacher Quality Index: A Protocol For Teacher Selection

The Teacher Quality Index (TQI) is a hotly debated metric that seeks to quantify the effectiveness of teachers. Developed by researchers at Stanford University, the TQI has been used by school districts across the country to evaluate teachers and make decisions about their employment, salary, and professional development. However, the TQI has also been criticized for its lack of validity and reliability, as well as its potential for bias against certain groups of teachers.

The Teacher Quality Index: A Protocol for Teacher Selection

by James H. Stronge

4.1 out of 5

Language	:	English
File size	:	8771 KB
Text-to-Speech	:	Enabled
Screen Reader	:	Supported
Enhanced typesetting	:	Enabled
Word Wise	:	Enabled
Print length	:	181 pages

This article will provide an in-depth analysis of the TQI, examining its methodology, strengths, weaknesses, and implications for education policy.

Methodology

The TQI is based on three components:

* Student achievement growth: This is measured by the change in students' test scores from the beginning to the end of the school year. * Classroom observations: Trained observers evaluate teachers on a variety of criteria, such as their instructional practices, classroom management, and student engagement. * Feedback from students and parents: Teachers are evaluated on the basis of feedback from their students and parents.

The TQI uses a statistical model to combine these three components into a single score. This score is then used to rank teachers and make decisions about their employment, salary, and professional development.

Strengths

The TQI has several strengths:

* It is based on multiple measures of teacher effectiveness. This makes it more comprehensive than traditional evaluation methods, which often rely solely on student achievement growth. * It is objective and data-driven. The TQI is based on quantifiable data, which makes it less subjective than traditional evaluation methods. * It can be used to identify teachers who are struggling. The TQI can help school districts identify teachers who need additional support and professional development.

Weaknesses

The TQI also has several weaknesses:

* It is not always valid. Research has shown that the TQI is not always able to accurately measure teacher effectiveness. * It is not always reliable. The TQI can produce different results when used to evaluate the same teacher on different occasions. * It can be biased against certain groups of teachers. The TQI has been shown to be biased against teachers who work in high-poverty schools and teachers who teach students of color.

Implications for Education Policy

The TQI has had a significant impact on education policy. School districts across the country have used the TQI to evaluate teachers and make decisions about their employment, salary, and professional development. However, the TQI has also been criticized for its lack of validity and reliability, as well as its potential for bias against certain groups of teachers.

As a result of these concerns, some school districts have stopped using the TQI. Others have continued to use the TQI, but they have made changes to the way it is used. For example, some school districts have used the TQI only as a screening tool to identify teachers who need additional support and professional development.

The TQI is a controversial metric that has had a significant impact on education policy. While the TQI has some strengths, it also has some significant weaknesses. School districts should carefully consider the strengths and weaknesses of the TQI before using it to make decisions about teachers.

Additional Information

* [The Teacher Quality Index website](https://tqi.stanford.edu/) * [Research on the Teacher Quality Index](https://eric.ed.gov/?id=EJ103833) * [Criticism of the Teacher Quality Index](https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/answer-sheet/wp/2013/05/01/the-teacher-quality-index-is-a-recipe-for-bad-policy-harmful-to-students-and-teachers/)

The Teacher Quality Index: A Protocol for Teacher Selection

by James H. Stronge

4.1 out of 5